A new chapter in the world of commerce

October 2016 · Digital banking & BaaS · From the Ja Trgovac archive

First published in Croatian in Ja Trgovac, the Croatian retail trade magazine, October 2016 issue (pp. 66–68), as “Novo poglavlje u svijetu trgovine”. Republished here in English translation without changes. At the time, Goran was Pre-Sales Manager, BU Payment, at Asseco SEE. Figures, products and regulation are described as they stood in October 2016.

PSD2 brings a series of new rules, primarily for the financial world, but given its basic premises and goals, it also opens a completely new chapter in the world of commerce, which will no longer need an intermediary between itself and the consumer.

The mere mention of the EU administration usually makes merchants’ hair stand on end. Everyone still remembers the rules on crooked cucumbers and irregular apples whose only purpose, at least as the impression prevailed here, was to justify the existence of that same administrative machinery under the pretext of protecting the end consumer. But what few participants in the modern world of commerce know is that this same administration has in recent years been turning intensively toward giving merchants as much freedom as possible at certain key points of interaction with the end consumer, especially in the application of technology in everyday business. One of the main segments that has undergone, and is still undergoing, the greatest changes is certainly payment, i.e. all its electronic forms. It is absolutely clear that today no retail provider can call itself a participant in commerce as such unless it at least accepts card payments at the physical point of sale, and online retail itself has become a de facto standard.

All of the above applies to Croatia, and especially to the developed EU market. That is precisely why the EU administration mentioned above, instead of regulating the crookedness of cucumbers, is spending its resources on something much more useful and significant for the world of commerce. One of the first significant fruits of this initiative came into force in the middle of this year. This is EU Regulation 2015/751 (adopted in 2015), behind whose unexciting name lies a series of rules for financial institutions (in our country primarily banks) that regulate several important items in the Bank–Merchant–Consumer relationship. Here we will touch on the two most interesting for merchants, which concern card payments: the cap on so-called “interchange” (MIF) card fees and the rule requiring full transparency in the presentation of card fees charged to the merchant.

What is it about?

Every merchant with a POS device for payment cards is aware that when a sale of 100 kuna is paid by card, 2 or 3 (sometimes more) kuna of those 100 go to the Bank that provides the POS. If it was a Mastercard or Visa card from the bank that also owns the POS device, that fee was defined solely by that Bank. But if payment was made with a card from another Bank, the fee charged to the merchant includes, besides the bank’s margin, a fixed amount defined by the rules of those card companies, which represents the earnings of the bank that issued the card, the so-called MIF (multilateral interchange fee). This means that the Bank that owns the POS must pay that fixed percentage to the card giants, Mastercard and Visa, who then pass it on to the bank that issued the card. Until the regulation came into force, this fee was 1.3% or more, depending on the card and certain other parameters. So such a transaction could never be cheaper for the merchant than that, even if the Bank made no margin at all. The regulation lowered this fee to 0.2% or 0.3% depending on the card type, which automatically meant the possibility of a cheaper transaction for the Merchant. And so that the Merchant could even recognize the opportunity to lower the price of a card transaction, the regulation took care of this in its second part, which obliges banks to be transparent in presenting the structure of the fee charged to the merchant: it must be clearly stated what part of the fee represents the bank’s margin, what part the fixed international fees mentioned above, and what part the basic cost. This created room for the Merchant to negotiate and lower the price of the service.

But the European Commission did not stop there, and in subsequent regulations it clearly showed how favorably disposed it is toward Merchants. Not only that, but it clearly built into the foundations of future regulations an initiative to promote innovation and the use of modern technology in payments, an area that until then had been mostly reserved for the banking world. The main and most important regulation, which is currently shaking the banking world and requiring banks to reorganize their strategic plans, is the famous PSD2, the Payment Service Directive 2. This is a regulation issued by the European Banking Authority (EBA) which, upon entering into force on 12 January 2016, became binding on all EU (or EEA) member states, in the sense that they must adopt national laws based on it by 12 January 2018 at the latest. PSD2 brings a series of new rules, primarily for the financial world, but given its basic premises and goals, it also opens a completely new chapter in the world of commerce. At its core, PSD2 defines four basic goals: encouraging innovation, regulating the market, encouraging competition and consumer security. It sounds very simple, but what actually lies behind it brings some of the most significant changes in the financial world in the last few decades.

Changes are coming

It is a fact that the world of payments falls under strict regulatory rules, precisely in order to enable maximum trust based on the security of the entire system. For the same reason, this entire segment has traditionally fallen within the domain of banking and financial institutions. Merchants have therefore always needed an intermediary between themselves and the consumer for payments. PSD2 brings significant changes here. The regulation defines the basic preconditions for Merchants to handle certain payment instruments directly, without the mediation of a third party, i.e. a bank. The whole story rests on two basic preconditions: Merchants (and anyone else who is interested) are allowed, subject to relatively simple requirements, to become a “quasi” financial institution, and Banks are required to provide unified technical conditions for this new business model. As a practical example: today, a merchant that is also an online merchant, or has an advanced mobile app through which it processes payments, must connect to one of the payment service providers in order to accept payments with current account cards (so-called debit cards), pay the fees mentioned above, wait several days for the funds to reach its account, and so on. With the implementation of PSD2, merchants will be able to register as a PISP (Payment Initiation Service Provider) and thus, at the time of payment, directly access the customer’s current account and transfer the transaction funds to themselves. No intermediary and no additional fee. No waiting for payout. Of course, with the customer’s permission and subject to certain rules defined through registration. And all of this toward any EU bank, on the same principle defined by the technical rules mentioned above.

What does this ultimately mean for the merchant? First of all, the possibility of reducing transaction costs. But beyond that, it enables a far higher level of innovation. Mobile apps and web shops with loyalty programs and a payment option, but this time without an intermediary. Optimized management of financial resources. Greater end-customer engagement and higher turnover. Of course, investment in technology is unavoidable, but for today’s modern merchant that is everyday reality and the foundation of business anyway. And this time the advantages are extremely clear and far-reaching. Banks are in any case aware of the change this regulation brings, because according to the latest research by PricewaterhouseCoopers, almost 90% of European bankers are planning strategic changes as a direct consequence of PSD2 and the new elements it brings. Merchants have yet to recognize its advantages and the opportunities it opens up for them, and to define their position toward it for their own future. However, until these changes take place, things are still moving in our small market in terms of technological innovation in commerce.

We recently wrote about the option of simplified payment in online stores, where the user stores card data in a secure environment during the first purchase. This simplifies payment in every subsequent transaction because not all card data has to be entered. The next step is applying this through a mobile app.

The good news is that Merchants in our country have slowly started to apply both models. One of the largest shopping portals recently introduced this option, and alongside the famous Uber taxi service, one of the taxi companies recently introduced this possibility. When registering, users enter their card data into the mobile app, and from that moment they pay for their rides simply and quickly, with all the benefits of digital and mobile payment: an instant overview of the transaction, ride details and other useful data.

Messenger and Facebook

And data is exactly what today’s merchant needs in order to optimize its business to the maximum and offer customers exactly what they want. And who knows more about end customers than social networks? Where we go, who we go with, what we like, how much we are willing to spend? Facebook is the absolute king here, and the digital giant from California is very much aware of it. Aware that they know the habits of billions of consumers around the world, and that today’s business world is unimaginable without a presence on social networks, they are trying to capitalize on precisely this wealth of information and interdependence. One point connecting providers on one side and users on the other. It sounds powerful. And it is powerful.

As a first step in this direction, they recently enabled users in Messenger, through so-called “chatbots”, to receive a personalized offer in the course of ordinary chatting, in the form of a message from a virtual computer conversation partner, a bot, which through human-like interaction offers options, and then to pay immediately for the product or service offered or simply transfer money to a friend. The process takes place through human-like communication with these bots. For example, the user sends a message in the chat saying “Please pay MarkoB 50 kn”, or if buying a product, “Buy shoes at XY”. The bot may reply with the message “What size would you like?” or simply offer the user options based on their previous searches and preferences on the social network. The next step is to offer a similar service through Facebook itself, where personalized offers would connect users, merchants and, of course, payments, thus creating a powerful and unique platform that exploits the benefits of the digital age. Of course, there is considerable controversy around this way of using modern technology, especially with regard to anonymity. But it should also be kept in mind that by 2025, almost half of household income will be in the hands of members of the so-called millennial generation and the generation after them, the so-called “Z” generation. And since for them social networks are a way of life, anonymity is last on the list of negative things that new technologies bring. In fact, they are surely more worried about those crooked cucumbers from the beginning of the story. Which, in a few years, we will probably be paying for through social networks.


About the author

Goran Bosankić, Founder of PayconGoran Bosankić, ETA CPP, is the founder of Paycon, an independent payments and banking advisory. Fifteen-plus years across card acquiring, payment orchestration, EFTPOS, 3D Secure, core and digital banking and BaaS. Former CEO of ABC TECH Group and CRO of Field39. LinkedIn · goran@getpaycon.com · More about Paycon


More from the archive on the Insights page, and a full list of bylined work on Publications. If this topic is on your agenda, get in touch.