Closed-loop payment systems: the quiet revolution of Croatian retail
March 2025 · Data & loyalty in retail · From the Ja Trgovac archive
First published in Croatian in Ja Trgovac, the Croatian retail trade magazine, March 2025 issue (pp. 64–65), as “Zatvoreni sustavi plaćanja: tiha revolucija hrvatske maloprodaje”. Republished here in English translation without changes. At the time, Goran was working at Field39. Figures, products and regulation are described as they stood in March 2025.
Successful implementation of a closed-loop card system requires a strategic approach, good planning and gradual implementation. But merchants who succeed gain a powerful tool that enables them not only to understand their customers better, but also to create the personalized shopping experience that today’s consumers expect.
Imagine being able to know exactly what your customers like, when they shop and how much they spend, while rewarding them for their loyalty, making payment easier for them and achieving significant savings in operating costs. Sounds like every merchant’s dream? Well, not anymore. Croatian retail is undergoing a significant transformation thanks to closed-loop card systems, and many of our merchants are not yet even aware of their full potential. These systems give complete control over data on customers, their habits and preferences, which is key for making business decisions.
A money ecosystem
Think of them as a private money ecosystem inside your store or chain of stores. Unlike standard Visa or Mastercard cards, these systems work only within your retail network. That may sound limiting, but that is exactly where their strength lies. Apart from the fact that the cost of such a transaction is many times lower than a conventional card transaction, the possibilities such a system brings are enormous: from offering your customers practical so-called “gift cards”, to opening, through B2B cooperation with your existing suppliers and partners, a new channel of benefits for their employees while gaining new customers for yourself. Nor should we overlook the positive effect on cash flow when using top-up cards (the popular “prepaid”).
The gift card revolution
A particularly interesting segment is gift cards, which are getting a new lease of life in Croatia through closed-loop card systems. Sales of gift cards have grown dramatically since merchants switched to digital systems: customers love them because they are practical, and they bring merchants secure income and new customers. The range of products is varied and it is sometimes hard to choose the right present for someone, and gift cards solve exactly that problem. But a physical card is not necessarily the only form. Modern closed-loop payment systems also support other forms, such as the popular QR codes, which are easily distributed through apps or the web and are used across all sales channels.
Security and data protection
As far as security is concerned, Croatian and EU regulation is very strict, but also clear. GDPR has set high standards of data protection, which is actually good news. Merchants, or rather their suppliers who implement closed-loop card systems, must ensure top-level data encryption and regular security checks, but in return they get a system that customers trust. An additional advantage is certainly that merchants, together with their suppliers of such solutions, form a closed circle in terms of the distribution of confidential data, thereby reducing risk for themselves and for their customers. Their role in the whole process is made even easier with suppliers that offer the entire system in the so-called “SaaS” (Software as a Service) model, where the whole solution sits in the supplier’s strictly closed and controlled environment.
A new era of loyalty programs
Loyalty programs are experiencing a true renaissance through these systems. Forget those boring cards where you collect points for months to get a token discount. The new systems enable personalized offers in real time, based on customers’ actual habits. The system immediately recognizes what might interest a customer and can offer relevant discounts in various forms and through various channels before the customer is even aware of the need. Through a closed-loop payment system, merchants have access to a far richer set of real-time transaction data, a luxury they can very rarely afford with conventional systems.
The technical side of the story
The technical side is not as daunting as it may seem at first glance. The key lies in good preparation and gradual implementation. Merchants often think they need to have all the functionality straight away, but the best approach is to start with a basic set of capabilities and upgrade the system according to customers’ needs.
The heart of the system is primarily a central closed-loop payment system that processes transactions in real time and enables numerous other upgrades, as well as insight into spending and transactions without any delay. Connected to this are the POS terminals in the stores, the website and mobile apps for customers, and system administration, which with the better solutions can be easily integrated into the merchant’s existing processes, further simplifying daily operations with such systems.
Challenges and investment
Of course, it is not all rosy. Implementing such a system requires a certain initial investment, and besides the software and hardware themselves, staff must be trained and customers prepared for the changes. However, the return on investment is usually very fast, often within the first year of operation, and suppliers of such systems frequently offer a so-called SaaS option, where merchants have a simple monthly usage cost that is easily absorbed by the increased sales volume through the system.
The future has already arrived
The future? It is already here. Croatian merchants are already experimenting with integrating blockchain technology into their closed-loop systems and developing hybrid solutions that combine the best of closed and open systems. Artificial intelligence is slowly entering the game, enabling even more precise prediction of customer behavior and automation of marketing activities. A particularly exciting trend is the integration of Internet of Things (IoT) devices with card systems. Smart shelves, digital price tags and automated checkouts are becoming reality, and closed-loop card systems serve as the central point connecting all these technologies into a single user experience, with a far more flexible approach than open card systems.
A significant competitive advantage
Successful implementation of a closed-loop card system requires a strategic approach, good planning and gradual implementation. But merchants who succeed gain a powerful tool that enables them not only to understand their customers better, but also to create the personalized shopping experience that today’s consumers expect.
Finally, it is important to note that closed-loop card systems are not a magic wand that will solve all the problems in retail. But they are a powerful tool that, when properly implemented and used, can bring a significant competitive advantage. Croatian merchants who have recognized this are already reaping the rewards of their decision, and those still thinking about implementation had better hurry. Because in today’s, to put it mildly, “dynamic” retail environment, every cent counts, in whatever format it comes, because it symbolizes the most valuable thing in retail: customer trust.
About the author
Goran Bosankić, ETA CPP, is the founder of Paycon, an independent payments and banking advisory. Fifteen-plus years across card acquiring, payment orchestration, EFTPOS, 3D Secure, core and digital banking and BaaS. Former CEO of ABC TECH Group and CRO of Field39. LinkedIn · goran@getpaycon.com · More about Paycon
More from the archive on the Insights page, and a full list of bylined work on Publications. If this topic is on your agenda, get in touch.