Revolution is knocking at the door
April 2018 · Stablecoins, deposit tokens & on-chain payments · From the Ja Trgovac archive
First published in Croatian in Ja Trgovac, the Croatian retail trade magazine, April 2018 issue (pp. 48–49), as “Revolucija kuca na vrata”. Republished here in English translation without changes. At the time, Goran was working at PayOut. Figures, products and regulation are described as they stood in April 2018.
Today we find ourselves in a situation similar to the one some 20 years ago, when the dot-com movement brought a revolution. A technology has appeared that carries a similar stigma, but that also brings the greatest changes since the dot-com era, ready to transform many industries and, among other things, profoundly change the world of commerce: blockchain.
“If I had asked people what they wanted, they would have told me they wanted a faster horse!” This statement, attributed to the famous Henry Ford, speaks to how innovation and drastic change are always pushed by visionaries and by people who anticipate, rather than merely record, the needs of the market. Otherwise, innovations defined by the market would mostly be about improving existing things.
In retail, it often happens that customers do not even know what they need until it appears on the market, whether as a new product or as a technology that fundamentally changes a particular industry. Twenty or more years ago it was the dot-com movement, which shaped not only the way we would shop in the years to come but the lifestyle of modern society in general. Companies like Amazon, eBay and PayPal are synonymous with commerce today and are household names. But in their very beginnings they were exotic, used mostly by enthusiasts and technology lovers, and, according to public opinion, mostly doomed to fail as a passing and unnecessary game. For today’s everyday user of their services, often born at a time when the technology had already taken hold, it is hard to understand how anyone could have resisted something that speeds up, eases and ultimately simplifies the process.
But since life has its repeating cycles, today we find ourselves in a situation similar to the one 20+ years ago. A technology has appeared that carries a similar stigma, but that also brings the greatest changes since the dot-com era, ready to transform many industries and, among other things, profoundly change the world of commerce: blockchain.
A high-potential platform
What actually is blockchain? Going into detail would take more than this entire issue, but in one sentence it is a distributed, encrypted record of information that, once written and confirmed on the network, can no longer be changed or deleted, and can be accessed at any time. Shutting down a blockchain would mean shutting down the internet and every one of the millions of computers participating in the chain. If even one computer exists, the record is on it. The best-known representative is certainly the famous Bitcoin, which started the whole buzz around the technology as an independent, decentralized means that can be used to transfer value (read: payment). But the real revolution came with the Ethereum network, a blockchain that made it possible to develop a multitude of other services on blockchain technology using the concept of so-called smart contracts. While the blockchain on which Bitcoin is based serves only one purpose, bitcoin, the Ethereum network simply makes it possible to develop programs for various purposes that fundamentally use blockchain technology and all the advantages it brings: decentralization, immutability, trust, traceability and availability. On top of that, the Ethereum network supported the function that bitcoin has, value, with its own carrier of value: the token.
It did not take long for the advantages of this technology to be recognized, and over the past two years a multitude of interesting projects and solutions have appeared in various industries that promise a complete change in the way business is done.
Slovenia first in the world
Retail is not immune to this. On the contrary, some of the largest projects cover precisely this industry, from simple concepts involving payment with cryptocurrencies (Bitcoin and other tokens) to extremely advanced solutions designed for specific purposes in the retail industry.
And closer than you can imagine: in our neighborhood. At the very mention of blockchain technology, many industry participants in the region, and even globally, think of one thing: Slovenia. Yes, our neighbors took advantage of early momentum, domestic know-how, capital and smart management and became a global leader in the field of the technology that is currently number one in the whole world. There is no doubt that we in Croatia also benefit from the fact that the technological revolution the whole world is talking about is right on our doorstep. Today Slovenia is truly ahead in blockchain projects, and when it comes to ICOs (“Initial Coin Offerings”), the method of financing blockchain projects by raising funds in exchange for tokens as carriers of value, Slovenia is first in the world in ICOs per capita! Truly impressive.
Of the many projects, the most interesting ones related to retail are certainly Eligma and OriginTrail. The Eligma project is an advanced e-commerce platform that plans to become a new Amazon based on blockchain technology with strong support from artificial intelligence technology. They showed they are serious as early as April, when they demonstrated part of the system together with their Slovenian retail partner, BTC in Ljubljana, the largest shopping center in Slovenia. Features such as payment with cryptocurrencies, predicting the best price for selling used goods, direct sales without intermediaries, a mobile wallet and the like are just some of the things our neighbors will soon be using to improve the shopping experience, whether online or in stores. OriginTrail is another Slovenian project that uses the immutability and traceability features that blockchain provides. The basic premise of the project is to increase the overall security and traceability of food distribution, so as to enable, in a secure and reliable way, the traceability of a product from the field to the consumer’s table. Although there were similar attempts in the past using conventional technologies, high costs and the possibility of malicious falsification of results doomed such initiatives to failure, except for a few major producers. Through OriginTrail and the use of blockchain technology, such a tracking system would become available to both small and large players, at low cost and with an almost irrefutable degree of information security. In short, new technologies enable us to get the product we want, when we want it, and with a greater degree of trust than ever before. It sounds a little utopian, but widespread application is just at the door, and in our case also just across the border!
The delayed PSD2 reality
However, until innovative technologies break through to the broad masses, our good old money in a bank account is still “king”, and the diligent bureaucrats decided to give us a “faster horse” through a regulation that has already been described countless times: PSD2. The initial enthusiasm about this revolutionary legislative change, intended to unify the EU market for payments and financial services by opening banks up to third parties and encouraging innovation, faded after numerous delays in defining and adopting the law. Still, the regulation is here: it came into force on 13 January this year, and national legislation was supposed to implement it on the same or a similar date. Of course, this did not happen, so Croatia is still behind on this (Slovenia, for example, has already passed the law), and we hope the law will be passed soon and thereby officially open the way for innovative services based on this regulation.
What does this actually mean for merchants? Unfortunately, still very little. The main brake on adopting the new rules is the enormous delay and months-long debate around the fundamental technical document, the RTS (Regulatory Technical Standards). The RTS is the “cookbook” that defines how the regulation will be implemented and thereby defines innovative business models. The agony lasted for months and ended in February this year, but it led to a situation in which the law has come into force while Banks have 18 months to adapt, which in practice means they do not have to comply with the law until that period expires. The long-awaited change is so far producing no visible results. Banks are cautiously preparing, making use of the statutory implementation period, and the certification process itself for an entity in the PSD2 environment is quite rigorous and almost insurmountable for most participants in e-commerce in our market. Whether this will open the door to consolidation of these services through larger players, and thereby bring the long-awaited innovation, whether through new services in e-commerce or even in physical retail, remains to be seen in the period ahead. But in the context of our horse from the beginning of the story, whether faster or slower, the most important thing of all is that it is moving forward.
About the author
Goran Bosankić, ETA CPP, is the founder of Paycon, an independent payments and banking advisory. Fifteen-plus years across card acquiring, payment orchestration, EFTPOS, 3D Secure, core and digital banking and BaaS. Former CEO of ABC TECH Group and CRO of Field39. LinkedIn · goran@getpaycon.com · More about Paycon
More from the archive on the Insights page, and a full list of bylined work on Publications. If this topic is on your agenda, get in touch.