The loyal and valuable quarter

May 2016 · Data & loyalty in retail · From the Ja Trgovac archive

First published in Croatian in Ja Trgovac, the Croatian retail trade magazine, May 2016 issue (pp. 72–73), as “Vjerna i vrijedna četvrtina”. Republished here in English translation without changes. At the time, Goran was Pre-Sales Manager, BU Payment, at Asseco SEE. Figures, products and regulation are described as they stood in May 2016.

The “golden ratio” of customer loyalty in retail tells us that the 25% of loyal customers generate a total of 75% of a merchant’s revenue, while the remaining 75% of occasional or one-time customers generate only 25% of revenue.

By one dry technical definition, loyalty means the ratio of a user’s preference for a service or product from a particular provider relative to other providers of the same (or similar) services or products. Within this dry, broad and complex definition, there is actually hidden one single word that expresses what loyalty essentially is: a relationship. If we add the other concepts we associate with a relationship, above all faithfulness, then appreciation, connection and participation, we arrive at the real definition of loyalty.

The backbone of business

From the retail perspective, loyalty programs, or “programi vjernosti” as we call them in Croatian, form the backbone of the day-to-day business of almost all merchants. They have existed since the 18th century, when certain merchants gave copper coins in return for frequent purchases, which could be used to cover part of a future purchase or exchanged for a free item. Whether simple programs of collecting stickers that we exchange for a free item, collecting points that we exchange for a discount, or participating in complex programs based on a contractual relationship with, for example, a telecom operator, there is no household that does not participate in some loyalty program. They all differ in how they are run and in their rewards, but in essence they all come down to the same premise: keep the customer and motivate them to spend more. Although at first glance this seems an easy task, the numbers are exact and show us how wrong this assumption really is. The “golden ratio” of customer loyalty in retail tells us that 25% of loyal customers generate a total of 75% of a merchant’s revenue, while the remaining 75% of occasional or one-time customers generate only 25% of revenue.

And here we come to the reason why there are real loyalty programs and those that merely call themselves that. The key lies precisely in segmenting these categories through a good loyalty program: motivating loyal customers, growing their base, and “letting go” of disloyal customers, i.e. those who buy only discounted items and thus often generate a cost or only a marginal profit for the merchant. But how can this segmentation be achieved? The answer is given by the golden concept of the modern age: data, or the popular “Big Data”.

Data and technology

The speed at which data is being collected globally today is downright frightening. According to the latest research, 98% of the data recorded in the world was generated in the last two years! It is precisely this immeasurable amount of data that makes up Big Data, a vast forest of zeros and ones waiting to become information, a tool that will enable someone to increase sales, retain an existing customer or win a new one. It is precisely with the help of data that a personalized approach to every customer is achieved: their key characteristics are recognized and an offer tailored just for them is shaped accordingly. A 2014 study on this topic by the respected Gartner Group predicts that by 2018, companies that successfully apply a personalized approach to their clients will increase their sales by at least 20% compared with companies that do not. A 20% increase in sales purely by using what is already available certainly deserves attention. And how can all this vast data be put to use? There is one answer: technology. This entire issue would not be enough to list all the technological innovations and concepts in retail related to loyalty programs. However, given global trends, we can single out a few that stand out either for their technological innovation or for the concept itself.

Gamification and Bluetooth

“Gamification”, a loyalty program concept in which the client is guided through the program using elements of a game, has exploded in recent years with the rise of social networks and the standardization of the mobile channel as the primary one in every respect. The concept is based on the psychological phenomenon known as the Zeigarnik effect, which essentially shows that the human mind develops a certain attachment to, and focuses on, unfinished tasks, while almost automatically ignoring completed ones. Loyalty programs that ask the customer to complete certain tasks in order to earn a reward, accompanied by various graphic displays of progress, have proved far more successful than programs with a simple “one condition = one reward” collection method.

Combined with a personalized approach and integration with social networks (for example, posting progress on one’s profile while tagging the merchant’s location and name, commenting on and rating products as part of a task, and so on), such programs represent for many merchants the future of reward programs, especially through the online channel.

In terms of technology, apart from the mobile channel, which is of course now obligatory, one of the most interesting developments of the last few years is BLE (Bluetooth Low Energy) “beacon”, i.e. transmitter, technology. The concept is based on stand-alone, independent devices that use Bluetooth communication in BLE mode and thus enable interaction with a mobile device without a complicated pairing procedure and with low battery consumption. How does it all work? The idea is that a user with a mobile app receives personalized information or an offer on the screen of their mobile device when they enter the zone of a BLE transmitter. Behind it all is a system that carefully analyzes the collected data and proposes the optimal offer based on the user’s micro-location, obtained through the app and the BLE transmitter. How does this work in practice? One of the most interesting implementations is in restaurants. A QSR restaurant chain in San Francisco in the US equipped every table with a BLE transmitter. Combined with a mobile app and integration with their system, this allowed the waiter to greet each guest who is a loyalty program member individually, propose a personalized offer based on previous visits, and optimize the use of collected points and rewards. Simple, modern and a great user experience.

Another example is the New York health food retail chain “Duane Reade”. BLE transmitters strategically placed around the store guide users through a mobile app, provide personalized purchase suggestions in real time, as well as exchange of points for discounts and products, and precisely direct users to the sections where, based on data on previous purchases, there is considered to be purchasing potential.

Since the purchase decision is almost always made in real time, shaping the customer’s decision on the spot in this way would be impossible, or much more difficult, without the help of these technologies. But what should certainly be kept in mind is that even the best ideas mean nothing if the execution does not live up to them.

Loyalty pays off

There is a fine line between a subtle suggestion to the user and an aggressive approach, where it is very easy to achieve the opposite of the desired effect. That is why, when creating a loyalty program, besides choosing the right technology and concept, it is extremely important to carefully design the experience from the customer’s perspective. Whether it is a health food store, a restaurant, a hotel or a wholesale chain, the key to every successful loyalty program is to ask the right questions at the very beginning: Who are my customers? What do I want to achieve with the program? Whom do I want to motivate? How much am I prepared to invest? How will I track the program’s life cycle? If you do not have an answer to each of these questions, the investment in a loyalty program will miss its mark, and the entire reward fund will probably end up in the hands of the 75% of customers who buy only discounted items. Careful planning, applicable technology, a personalized approach, an extremely simplified user experience and a clear strategic vision will lead to the desired result. Fred Reichheld, the creator of the best-known and most widely used metric in the world of loyalty programs, the so-called NPS (Net Promoter Score), claims that an increase of just 5% in client/customer retention produces an increase in profitability of as much as 25%. Why? Because loyal customers come back and buy even more. And since winning a new customer requires an investment as much as seven times greater than retaining an existing one, the calculation is clear regardless of the technology: loyalty really does pay off.


About the author

Goran Bosankić, Founder of PayconGoran Bosankić, ETA CPP, is the founder of Paycon, an independent payments and banking advisory. Fifteen-plus years across card acquiring, payment orchestration, EFTPOS, 3D Secure, core and digital banking and BaaS. Former CEO of ABC TECH Group and CRO of Field39. LinkedIn · goran@getpaycon.com · More about Paycon


More from the archive on the Insights page, and a full list of bylined work on Publications. If this topic is on your agenda, get in touch.